Mealey Publications™

TOP STORIES

3rd Circuit: Traditional Rules Apply In Legal Publishers’ AI Copyright Fight

PHILADELPHIA — The Third Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals became at least the second federal appellate court to address artificial intelligence copyright issues after unsealing an opinion finding that while the technology is new, traditional principles govern the case and that a legal research competitor’s use of copyrighted material was not fair use.

Split 9th Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Challenges To Campaign Media Spending Law

SAN FRANCISCO — A divided Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals panel on Sept. 30 affirmed a lower court’s dismissal of challenges by Americans for Prosperity and Americans for Prosperity Foundation to Arizona’s Voters’ Right to Know Act, which implemented disclosure requirements for funds spent on campaign media, rejecting the argument that the law is facially unconstitutional and finding that the as-applied free-speech challenge is conclusory.

Judge Confirms 3 ICSID Awards In Assignee’s Favor Against Spain

WASHINGTON, D.C. — A District of Columbia federal judge on Sept. 30 denied the Kingdom of Spain’s motion to dismiss or stay a petition to confirm three International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) arbitral awards against it collectively worth nearly 90 million euros plus costs and interest and entered judgment for all three awards in favor of an entity to which the original award-creditors assigned their interests.

Pa. Federal Judge Denies ‘Meritless’ Motion For DNA Testing In Fracking Death Suit

HARRISBURG, Pa. — Going “one step further” than the response in opposition, a Pennsylvania federal judge held that a motion filed by the last remaining defendant in a lawsuit brought by the estate of a man who died while working at a natural gas drilling site to compel genetic testing of two children listed as beneficiaries was “meritless” and precluded by limitations prescribed by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35.

Split D.C. Circuit Grants Emergency Motion To Halt Carving Trump’s Name On Façade

WASHINGTON, D.C. — A split District of Columbia Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals panel on Sept. 30 granted an emergency motion by U.S. Institute of Peace (USIP) and its board seeking to prevent federal government parties from allegedly “carrying out plans to carve President [Donald J.] Trump’s name into the façade of the iconic USIP headquarters building”; the motion was filed in a case in which the USIP parties are challenging Trump’s authority to have fired them in March 2025.

Illinois Federal Judge Declines Supplemental Jurisdiction In Relator Share Dispute

CHICAGO — A pharmacist who filed a qui tam complaint against Walgreens Boots Alliance Inc., Walgreen Co. and various subsidiaries (collectively, Walgreens) on allegations that the company violated federal law by filling millions of invalid controlled-substance prescriptions and seeking payment through Medicare and other federal health care programs must turn to state courts to resolve his claims that 28 states owe him a portion of the funds they recovered in a multistate agreement reached with Walgreens and in a settlement to end federal claims reached after the government intervened.

Judge Dismisses Sugary Snacks Deceptive Labeling Class Suit With Prejudice

SAN DIEGO — A California federal judge on Sept. 29 granted a fruit snack maker’s motion to dismiss a putative class action lawsuit against it for allegedly violating California’s unfair competition law (UCL) by labeling its gummy snacks as “Made with Real Fruit Juice,” finding that the product does contain pear concentrate and that a reasonable consumer would not be deceived by the label, and denied the plaintiff leave to amend.

Legal Advocacy Group Seeks To Enjoin OpenAI Agents From Hacking

SAN FRANCISCO — A legal advocacy group filed suit Sept. 29 in a California court under the state’s unfair competition law seeking to enjoin OpenAI entities’ artificial intelligence models from accessing computers, networks or systems without authorization in the wake of allegations that the company’s AI agents hacked third-party websites.

Class Action Certified Against Company Over Lead Levels In Tampons

SAN DIEGO — A California federal judge on Sept. 29 granted a woman’s motion to certify a statewide class bringing claims against a tampon manufacturer for violating California’s unfair competition law (UCL) and other laws by allegedly misrepresenting its tampons as safe when they in fact contained lead in its tampons and granted in part and denied in part a defense motion to exclude the plaintiff’s expert witness.

10th Circuit Sides With Boilermakers In Early Retirement Benefits Case

DENVER — Resolving cross-appeals filed after the class in an early retirement benefits dispute concerning a multiemployer fund obtained a judgment in the amount of $24,851,056, the 10th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals on Sept. 29 revived fiduciary breach claims asserted by 66 boilermakers but otherwise affirmed the trial court.

Pennsylvania Federal Judge Upholds 15% Prepayment Rule For IRS Promoter Penalties

PITTSBURGH —  Ruling on what he called an issue of first impression concerning the constitutionality of the Internal Revenue Code’s (IRC) 15% prepayment requirement, a Pennsylvania federal judge denied renewed motions for dismissal and for summary judgment filed by a Pittsburgh-based corporation challenging more than $6.5 million in promoter penalties tied to a purported captive insurance program, applying in part a constitutional originalism analysis of the Seventh Amendment to determine that the requirement does not violate the right to a jury trial because it is analogous to founding-era requirements that parties whose assets are at risk post security before trial.

LATEST NEWS

Judge Certifies Monitoring Class In Lead Exposure Suit, Not Personal Injury Class
Scientific Impossibility Means Claims Weren’t Enabled, Says Federal Circuit
Split Federal Circuit Won’t Reconsider Antibody Patent JMOL Reversal
3rd Circuit: Traditional Rules Apply In Legal Publishers’ AI Copyright Fight
Federal Circuit: Judge Didn’t Fully Explain Fee Denial After Section 101 Ruling
9th Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of DMCA Claims Over AI-Generated Code
3rd Circuit: Professor’s Copyright Claims Over AI Course Properly Dismissed
Federal Circuit Affirms Trade Secret Win After Damages Arguments Forfeited
Rehearing Petition Denied After Remand Order In Baby Formula Interlocutory Appeal
New York Federal Judge Finds Treasury Data Access Claims Moot After DOGE Dissolves
Judge: Plaintiffs Failed To Support RICO, Antitrust Claims Over Fracking Leases
Judge Won’t Dismiss Playboy Photo Copyright Suit, Rejecting Fair Use Argument
On Remand, Judge Again Confirms $136M Award Against India In Satellite Dispute
Split 9th Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Challenges To Campaign Media Spending Law
Judge Confirms 3 ICSID Awards In Assignee’s Favor Against Spain
Pa. Federal Judge Denies ‘Meritless’ Motion For DNA Testing In Fracking Death Suit
Judge Limits Experts, Causation Testimony As Talc Case Heads To Trial
Split D.C. Circuit Grants Emergency Motion To Halt Carving Trump’s Name On Façade
Judge Dismisses Federal Antitrust Claim Over Microsoft-OpenAI Compute Deal
Judge Again Grants Summary Judgment For Defendant In Lens Patent Infringement Case
Illinois Federal Judge Declines Supplemental Jurisdiction In Relator Share Dispute
Judgment Granted In Part In GEICO RICO Dispute With Physician, Medical Practice
Investors Fail To Plead Scienter In Fraud Suit Against Clinical Research Company
Failure To Link Pump Malfunction To Manufacturing Defect Dooms Claims, Judge Says
Mass Tort Cases For Drugs, Medical Devices
Judge Denies Motion To Dismiss Wrongful Death Case Involving Risperdal Use
Certification Of 2 Classes Upheld In Classmates.com Publicity Rights Case
Magistrate Partly Dismisses Former Insurance Mogul’s Suit Alleging NDA Violations
Wisconsin Federal Judge: Sharing Waived Protection Of Expert Witness Draft
Bankruptcy Judge OKs Disclosure Statement For Uniroyal Debtors’ Plan