Policy & Compliance
-
November 04, 2025
5th Circ. Judge Says FCA Illegally Steps On Executive Power
Fifth Circuit Judge James C. Ho says his court should reconsider what he called "serious constitutional problems with the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act," arguing that whistleblowers who sue under the law "are neither appointed by, nor accountable to, the president," and that conflicts with presidential authority.
-
November 04, 2025
Judges Wade Into Abortion Pill Access And Rx Pricing Fights
In a flurry of recent legal activity, courts across the country have been drawn into the nation's most contentious healthcare debates over access to medication abortions and efforts to cap the cost of prescription medications.
-
November 04, 2025
Meet The Attys Behind Drugmakers' Conn. Price Cap Suit
Attorneys from Goodwin Procter LLP and Wiggin and Dana LLP are teaming up to represent the Association for Accessible Medicines in its challenge to a Connecticut drug price cap set to take effect at the start of 2026.
-
November 04, 2025
NY Court Splits On Emotional Damage From Fatal Birth Injury
New York’s highest court handed a loss to legal advocates who had hoped a mother’s suit over the ramifications of the death of her newborn baby would help overturn a 20-year-old precedent on prenatal torts. A dissenting judge called a legal barrier to emotional damage recovery “contrary to common sense.”
-
November 04, 2025
Fed. Circ. Denies VA Surgeon's Wrongful Termination Appeal
The Federal Circuit on Tuesday affirmed the U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board's decision to uphold the firing of a general surgeon by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs after he raised concerns about compromised patient care.
-
November 04, 2025
9th Circ. Revives Ore. Right To Life Suit: 3 Things To Know
A divided Ninth Circuit panel sided with an Oregon anti-abortion group last week and reinstated its lawsuit challenging a state law that requires health plans to cover abortion and contraceptives.
-
November 04, 2025
HHS Watchdog Puts Failing Nursing Home Program On Blast
Hefty fines aren’t enough to turn around the nation's worst nursing homes, a government watchdog has concluded. The findings illustrate the need for new enforcement strategies that promote staffing and other improvements meant to last.
-
November 04, 2025
End Payors Seek $66M In Atty Fees In Generic Drug MDL
End payors in a generic drug price-fixing multidistrict litigation are seeking a Pennsylvania federal court's approval for a $66 million award of attorney fees, representing one-third of the $200 million settlement between the classes and Sun Pharmaceutical Industries Inc. and Taro Pharmaceuticals USA Inc.
-
November 03, 2025
Pharmacies Seek Cert. In Cholesterol Drug Price-Fixing MDL
A group of indirect reseller plaintiffs urged a Pennsylvania federal judge on Friday to certify a nationwide class of thousands of pharmacies that indirectly purchased the cholesterol medication pravastatin in sprawling multidistrict litigation over alleged price-fixing in the generic drug industry.
-
November 03, 2025
FDA Official Quits As Aurinia Sues Over 'Personal Vendetta'
Aurinia Pharmaceuticals on Sunday launched a lawsuit accusing Dr. George Tidmarsh, who that same day resigned as head of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's drug division, of falsely claiming the biotech's lupus nephritis drug doesn't work amid his "longstanding personal vendetta" against the company's board chair and investor.
-
November 03, 2025
Judge Denies New Trial In SuperValu Whistleblower Drug Case
An Illinois federal judge has refused to grant a new trial to whistleblowers who said grocery chain SuperValu systematically overbilled the government for prescription drugs, finding there was no issue with jury instructions on causation.
-
November 03, 2025
Colorado Judge Denies AbbVie's Bid To Block State Drug Law
A Colorado federal judge denied AbbVie Inc.'s bid for a preliminary injunction, which would have barred the state from enforcing its laws and penalties surrounding federal 340B drug pricing.
-
October 31, 2025
Drugmakers Can't End States' Dermatology Price-Fixing Suits
A Connecticut federal judge on Friday refused to throw out the vast majority of claims in a nationwide antitrust enforcement action accusing a long list of pharmaceutical companies of fixing the prices of generic dermatology drugs, rejecting the companies' argument that the claims were filed too late.
-
October 31, 2025
Amgen Again Challenges Colo. Price Cap For Arthritis Drug
Amgen has once again sued Colorado over its price cap for the arthritis drug Enbrel, claiming that the Centennial State's drug price-control statute violates the U.S. Constitution, conflicts with federal patent law and threatens patients' access to lifesaving medications.
-
October 31, 2025
Hawaii Judge Declares FDA's Mifepristone Regs Unlawful
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration failed to sufficiently justify restrictions on the abortion drug mifepristone, a Hawaii federal judge ruled in an order declaring the restrictions unlawful under the Administrative Procedure Act.
-
October 31, 2025
Aetna Strikes $650K Deal In Lipedema Patients' Coverage Suit
Aetna has agreed to pay up to $650,000 to resolve a class action claiming it unlawfully refused to cover liposuction for over two dozen patients with a rare condition called lipedema, according to a filing in California federal court.
-
October 31, 2025
Garnet Health Inks $4.6M Deal In Retirement Fee, Fund Suit
Garnet Health Medical Center has agreed to fork over $4.6 million to end a proposed class action alleging the New York healthcare network mismanaged employee retirement plan fees and investments, according to settlement documents filed by workers Friday in New York federal court.
-
October 31, 2025
3 Argument Sessions Benefits Attys Should Watch In Nov.
The Third Circuit will hear a union's appeal in a withdrawal liability battle, a union health plan defends its partial win in a coverage fight at the Ninth Circuit, and pharmacy benefit managers will take a challenge to the Federal Trade Commission's authority to the full Eighth Circuit. Here are three arguments to keep an eye on in November.
-
October 31, 2025
NC Attorney General, HCA Duel Over Merger Commitments
The North Carolina Attorney General's Office and HCA Healthcare have offered competing interpretations of a 2019 merger agreement in their efforts to secure a pretrial win in the state's compliance case involving the purchase of an Asheville hospital system.
-
October 30, 2025
J&J's Janssen Says 3rd Circ. Should Reverse $1.6B FCA Win
Johnson & Johnson's Janssen Products LP urged the Third Circuit to overturn a $1.6 billion False Claims Act judgment over two of its HIV drugs, arguing the district court allowed whistleblowers to prove fraud based solely on "off-label" marketing rather than any false claim actually submitted to the government.
-
October 30, 2025
Generic-Drug Firms Want To Fast-Track Conn. Price Cap Fight
An industry group for generic and biosimilar pharmaceutical companies has asked a Connecticut federal judge to fast-track its lawsuit seeking to block the state's new drug price cap, claiming it will suffer "imminent harm" if the case is delayed.
-
October 30, 2025
Judge Unpauses 'Important' Suit Over Vax Guidelines
A Massachusetts federal judge agreed Thursday to lift a government shutdown-related stay of litigation challenging new COVID-19 vaccine recommendations for children and pregnant women, calling the case a "matter of national importance" that warrants keeping the case moving over the U.S. Department of Justice's objection.
-
October 30, 2025
Health Group Urges 1st Circ. To Deny FCA Suit Fee Challenge
A Massachusetts health network has asked the First Circuit to deny a whistleblower's attempt to secure more attorney fees for a False Claims Act suit, arguing that a federal judge properly denied numerous claims for fees after a $2.5 million settlement.
-
October 30, 2025
Surgical Co. Gets Tobacco Fee ERISA Suit Kicked To Texas
A proposed class action alleging that a surgical center operator discriminated against workers who use tobacco by making them pay more for health coverage belongs in Texas, a Kentucky federal judge said, ruling that the business doesn't have enough connection to Kentucky.
-
October 29, 2025
DOJ Subpoena Called 'Pressure' To Ax Gender-Affirming Care
The U.S. Department of Justice issued a subpoena to intimidate a telehealth organization into ending gender-affirming medical care, a Seattle federal judge said in a ruling that found the agency is using the guise of an investigation to further the Trump administration's stated goal of eliminating transgender and gender-diverse patients' access to healthcare.
Gov't Subpoena Powers Face Reckoning In Healthcare Battles
The judicial deference given to the government's power to issue investigative subpoenas is facing an unprecedented challenge in transgender care cases. Willingness by judges to question motives could lead to more subpoena challenges or impede worthy government investigations.
Tylenol Autism Warning May Face Legal, Free Speech Hurdles
The Trump administration’s plan to add an autism warning to Tylenol's labeling could generate procedural and First Amendment challenges. Legal experts expect federal officials’ own words will be used against them.
Supreme Court Medina Ruling Erodes Public Health Networks
Healthcare advocates in more than a dozen states are bracing for Planned Parenthood's ouster from public benefit programs after a U.S. Supreme Court decision in June.
Expert Analysis
-
Calif. Justices Continued Anti-Arbitration Trend This Term
In the 2024-2025 term, the California Supreme Court justices continued to narrow arbitration's reach under state law, despite state courts' extreme caseload backlog and even as they embraced contractual autonomy in other contexts, says Josephine Petrick at The Norton Law Firm.
-
Steps For Healthcare Providers After Cigna ERISA Settlement
Following the Cigna class action's settlement, where Employee Retirement Income Security Act violations arose from Cigna's online provider directory advertising providers as in-network who were actually out-of-network, providers should routinely audit their contract status and directory listings, and proactively coordinate with plans and payor partners, say attorneys at ArentFox Schiff.
-
What's New In FDA's Latest Cell And Gene Therapy Guidance
New draft guidance from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, along with other recent initiatives, come together to promote cell and gene therapy product development by streamlining development and review pathways, say attorneys at Holland & Knight.
-
Adapting To Enforcement Focus On Wound Care Fraud
As federal agencies target wound care industry fraud as a top enforcement priority, attorneys advising industry stakeholders should evaluate business relationships for Anti-Kickback Statute violations, emphasize appropriate product use and documentation, and use internal data analytics to monitor billing patterns, say David Tarras at Tarras Defense and Jay McCormack at Verrill Dana.
-
AG Watch: Illinois A Key Player In State-Level Enforcement
Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul has systematically strengthened his office to fill federal enforcement gaps, oppose Trump administration mandates and advance state policy objectives, particularly by aggressively pursuing labor-related issues, say attorneys at Troutman.
-
Organ Transplant System Reforms Mark Regulatory Overhaul
Recent oversight, enforcement and operational developments in the U.S. organ procurement and transplantation system, alongside challenges like the federal shutdown, highlight heightened regulatory scrutiny and the need for compliance to maintain public trust, say attorneys at Hall Render.
-
Federal Grantees May Soon Face More Limitations On Speech
If courts accept the administration’s new interpretation of preexisting case law, which attempts to graft onto grant recipients the existing limitations on government contractors' free speech, a more deferential standard may soon apply in determining whether an agency’s refusal or termination of a grant was in violation of the First Amendment, say attorneys at Venable.
-
HHS Wound Care Report Highlights Need For Payment Reform
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services' recent report on potential abuse in Medicare Part B payments for skin substitutes highlights specific fraud schemes, but more importantly emphasizes that broader changes are needed for the wound care sector's fundamentally flawed payment system, say attorneys at Paul Hastings.
-
Assessing The Future Of The HIPAA Reproductive Health Rule
In light of a Texas federal court's recent decision to strike down a U.S. Department of Health and Human Services rule aimed to protect the privacy of patients seeking abortions and gender-affirming care, entities are at least temporarily relieved from compliance obligations, but tensions are likely to continue for the foreseeable future, says Liz Heddleston at Woods Rogers.
-
DOJ's Tracing Rule For Pandemic Loan Fraud Is Untenable
In conducting investigations related to COVID-19 relief fraud, the government's assertion that loan proceeds are nonfungible and had to have been segregated from other funds is unsupported by underlying legislation, precedent or the language establishing similar federal relief programs, say Sharon McCarthy, Jay Nanavati and Lasya Ravulapati at Kostelanetz.
-
New Health AI Guidance Features A Provider-Centric Approach
New guidance from the Joint Commission and Coalition for Health AI regarding the responsible use of artificial intelligence in healthcare deviates from preexisting guidance by recommending a comprehensive framework for using AI tools, focusing on healthcare provider organizations rather than on AI developers, say attorneys at Ropes & Gray.
-
Mass. Ruling May Pave New Avenue To Target Subpoenas
A Massachusetts federal court’s recent decision to quash a subpoena seeking information on gender-affirming care at Boston Children’s Hospital is a significant departure from courts' deferential approach to subpoena enforcement, and may open a new pathway for practitioners challenging investigative tools in the future, say attorneys at Gibson Dunn.
-
What To Expect After FDA Warnings To GLP-1 Compounders
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration's recent warning letters to companies advertising compounded versions of GLP-1 medications raise questions not just about the enforcement outlook for marketing such products, but also about the future of drug compounding as a whole, say attorneys at Spencer Fane.